Harvest Now, Decrypt Later: Why Quantum Is Already a Patient-Trust Problem

The quantum computer that breaks today's encryption doesn't exist yet.

But the attack already started.

It's called "harvest now, decrypt later," and the logic is brutally simple: attackers copy encrypted data today, store it, and wait. They don't need a quantum computer now. They need one eventually. And when that day comes, the data they harvested will be exactly as sensitive as it was the day they took it.

That last part is what makes healthcare different from almost every other industry facing this threat — and it's the part I want leaders to sit with.

A credit card number can be replaced. A password can be reset. A medical history cannot. A diagnosis, a genome, a child's record, a psychiatric history — these don't stop being private in ten years. They stay private for a lifetime. In England, maternity records are kept a minimum of 25 years; cancer records, 30 years from diagnosis. A patient record encrypted today with RSA or elliptic curve cryptography could, in principle, be decrypted by a quantum computer in 2035 — and everything in it would still matter.

So the question isn't really "when will quantum computers arrive?" Nobody knows the date, and the experts disagree by years. The Global Risk Institute's survey of experts puts a cryptographically relevant quantum computer as "quite possible" within ten years and "likely" within fifteen. Google's Craig Gidney estimated last year that RSA-2048 could be factored in under a week with fewer than a million noisy qubits — down from 20 million in a 2019 estimate. The timeline keeps compressing. But for a record that must stay confidential for 25 years, nobody needs to know the date. The math already says: the protection has to outlast the data, and the data outlives every encryption we use today.

And the numbers say we're not ready. Research published last month by Forescout's Vedere Labs, covering more than 2.5 million devices across 50-plus healthcare organizations, found that only 6% of connected medical devices use encryption implementations capable of supporting post-quantum cryptography — against 50% of traditional IT devices. Only about a third of internet-facing healthcare systems even run TLS 1.3, the version post-quantum protection requires. The five data types most at risk read like a hospital's core: electronic medical records, medical imaging, laboratory results, medication and prescription data, and financial data. Meanwhile, ransomware claims against healthcare providers rose 47% in the first eight months of this year.

None of this is a reason to panic. It is a reason to start.

Because something important changed recently: the uncertainty about what to do is largely gone. In August 2024, NIST finalized the first three post-quantum cryptography standards — ML-KEM for key exchange, ML-DSA and SLH-DSA for digital signatures. And last month, NIST published its final transition plan: the quantum-vulnerable algorithms we rely on today will be deprecated after 2030 and disallowed after 2035. Federal high-value systems must move to post-quantum key exchange by the end of 2030, and to post-quantum signatures a year later. Europe has set its own path — high-risk systems migrated by 2030, as much as feasible by 2035. The UK's National Cyber Security Centre wants discovery done by 2028 and priority migration by 2031.

The standards exist. The dates exist. What doesn't exist yet, in most health systems, is the decision to treat this as a today problem rather than a 2035 problem.

I spent years in direct patient care before I worked in health innovation, and the lesson I carried out of those years is simple: trust is the hardest thing to rebuild once it's lost. Patients tell us things in confidence because they believe we will protect what they told us. A breach that exposes a patient's record doesn't just cost money or trigger a notification letter. It costs the belief itself — and once a community stops believing the system will protect them, they stop telling it the truth. They delay care. They leave things out. The clinical consequences of lost trust are measured in outcomes, not in fines.

That is why I don't think of quantum as a technology story. I think of it as a stewardship story. Leaders don't need to be physicists to ask the right questions. They need to be stewards of data that will outlive every system holding it today.

So here are the questions I would put in front of any board or executive team this month:

Do you know where your organization's encryption lives — not just in the data center, but in the devices, the imaging systems, the vendor connections, the cloud services? Most organizations would be surprised by the answer, and the surprise is the point.

How long does your patients' data have to stay secret? Not how long your refresh cycle is. How long the data itself must remain confidential. If the answer is decades — and for a health system, it is — then the timeline for protecting it started yesterday.

And who owns this decision? Quantum readiness is nobody's full-time job in most organizations right now, which means it is everybody's part-time worry and nobody's accountability. The organizations that will be ready are the ones that name an owner before the deadline names one for them.

The quantum threat isn't a future event. It's a present decision — made in the budgets, the procurement choices, and the vendor conversations happening right now. The organizations that protect their patients' trust will be the ones that started asking the question before the answer arrived.

Want to explore what readiness looks like for your organization? Book a free Discovery Call (link to https://calendly.com/rn4students-rn4studentsnanosolutions/discovery-call) — no pressure, just an honest conversation about where you are and what comes next.

Valencia Annik Payne, MS Health Informatics/Healthcare Administration, BSN, RN

Certified AI Consultant™ | Healthcare AI Strategist | U.S. Navy Nurse Veteran

Learn more at https://www.rn4studentsnanosolutions.com/

Next
Next

Nanotechnology in Healthcare: Small Scale, Big Questions